Should I Choose iSCSI or Fibre Channel?

IT

Should I Choose iSCSI or Fibre Channel?

by Brad Fair

A storage area network, or SAN, is a major investment for any company. There are two types of SAN technology — iSCSI and Fibre Channel. There are several factors that go into deciding which technology is right for a particular application.

A SAN should be designed to grow with the needs of a company. Most companies that implement a SAN know that their storage needs are going to be growing rapidly over a short period of time. That is why it is important that your SAN remain as scalable as possible. In many cases scalability is ruled by the budget available to purchase new equipment, and when it comes to the budget, the best choice is iSCSI. Using iSCSI offers the ability to grow the storage network without breaking the bank. Fibre Channel storage solutions are typically very expensive.

Training a staff on implementing and maintaining a SAN can also cost a great deal of money. However, iSCSI is based on the same principles as a standard IP network. That means that there is very little training involved when it comes to understanding how to maintain and grow an iSCSI SAN. Fibre Channel requires a great deal of training, and in most cases it is necessary to hire someone who is a Fibre Channel specialist to run your Fibre Channel SAN.

Fibre Channel has its advantages in two ways over iSCSI. Fibre Channel is well known in many vertical markets, especially health care, and is therefore the SAN of choice. Fibre Channel is also faster than iSCSI. Fibre Channel has a speed of 800MB/s per channel, and does not come with a great deal of overhead. Because iSCSI uses the TCP/IP protocol, it carries a little more overhead.

The right SAN for you depends on your situation. If you are a data center looking to transfer small packets of data at a reasonable rate then an iSCSI network will be a great investment for you. The inexpensive iSCSI equipment, and the lack of training needed to have your IT department maintain your iSCSI SAN, make it perfect for a corporate setting.

In a video editing situation, or any situation where large packets of information need to travel at very high speeds, the best SAN is a Fibre Channel SAN. Fibre Channel SANS tend to be much more expensive than iSCSI, and they are traditionally installed in more specialized situations.

More About the Author

Brad Fair

Solutions Architect
Webcast Friday: Tableau Server Performance Monitoring On the second ever Webcast Friday that InterWorks has produced, I had the honor of speaking to our web audience about Tableau Server ...
The Desktop User’s Guide to Tableau Server Are you a Tableau Desktop user who is new to Tableau Server? Do you find yourself confounded by all of the thingamajigs and whatsits, ...

See more from this author →

Subscribe to our newsletter

  • I understand that InterWorks will use the data provided for the purpose of communication and the administration my request. InterWorks will never disclose or sell any personal data except where required to do so by law. Finally, I understand that future communications related topics and events may be sent from InterWorks, but I can opt-out at any time.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

InterWorks uses cookies to allow us to better understand how the site is used. By continuing to use this site, you consent to this policy. Review Policy OK

×

Interworks GmbH
Ratinger Straße 9
40213 Düsseldorf
Germany
Geschäftsführer: Mel Stephenson

Kontaktaufnahme: markus@interworks.eu
Telefon: +49 (0)211 5408 5301

Amtsgericht Düsseldorf HRB 79752
UstldNr: DE 313 353 072